Chapter 1
For 13 years, my parents left me to be raised by my grandmother. The one thing they always say to me is, "You're the one we feel we've let down the most."
Because of that, my parents always seem to favor me.
When Dad pays for my younger sister, Ruby Keller's, piano lessons, Mom turns to me and says she didn't want to put me through that kind of hardship.
Whenever Ruby refuses to do the housework, Dad says to me with a kind smile, "You should do more chores. It's good exercise. Don't be like that lazy bum. No one's going to want her when she grows up."
Every Christmas, our family takes a new group photo.
Dad stands on the left, Mom stands on the right, and Ruby stands in the middle. I always stand behind them.
Mom gently explains, "The angle is unflattering for the people in front. The back is the best spot."
So, the only part of me visible in our family photos was half an arm.
It's the same every year. Every time, I tell myself that my parents love me. They just show it differently from the way they love Ruby.
During my junior year of college, I come home for the holiday family photo. However, I end up arriving an hour late because the train was delayed.
The moment I step out of the station, I see a photo Mom posted in our family group chat.
Dad stands to the left, Mom stands to the right, and Ruby stands in the middle with an imposing dog beside her.
Dad sent a message.
"This is the most perfect family photo we've taken in years."
After that, the three of them flood the group chat with messages, enthusiastically discussing where to go for dinner after the photo shoot.
No one cared that I wasn't in the photo, and no one asked where I was or whether I'd eaten.
Something inside me suddenly gives way. I can't keep lying to myself anymore.
Without a word, I leave the family chat and fill out an application to study abroad as an exchange student.
A quiet and obedient person can also leave without making a sound.
Chapter 1
When the three of them returned, Mom was beaming as she held up the family photo. "Our Ruby gets prettier every year! She makes us so proud!"
Dad held the dog's leash in his left hand and a mountain of shopping bags in his right. My sister, Ruby Keller, was happily licking an ice cream.
The three of them had been happily enjoying themselves, but the moment they saw me, the cheerful atmosphere froze.
Mom was the first to recover and smile. "Clover, you're back! Why didn't you go inside?"
It was 98 degrees outside. I'd been waiting in the hallway for four hours, and sweat covered my body. My clothes were damp and clung to my skin.
I looked at her.
"I don't have fingerprint access."
I originally had access, but when I was in my senior year of high school and Ruby was a junior, I got home an hour later than she did.
Whenever I rode my bike home and unlocked the door, I'd inevitably disturb her.
The next day, Ruby coldly deleted my fingerprint. Mom simply smiled and took me to arrange for dorm accommodation.
"I'm doing this to teach you to be independent. Just look at your sister. Your dad and I don't even want to bother with her."
Mom clearly remembered the incident too. Looking embarrassed, she said, "Geez. You should've just called us then."
"I did."
Dad looked a little awkward. "It was pretty noisy outside. Maybe we didn't hear it."
Ruby casually pressed her finger against the scanner and opened the door.
I was just about to wheel in my suitcase when the dog suddenly started barking and baring its fangs at me.
Dad immediately crouched down and stroked its head.
"What's wrong, Lucky? Did Clover scare you?"
Ruby also bent down to soothe it. "He doesn't recognize Clover. Of course, he'd get nervous around a stranger."
Mom turned and headed toward the kitchen.
"I'll get him some treats."
Dad grabbed my suitcase for me. "Don't move yet. Give Lucky a moment to calm down."
I stood in the doorway, watching Mom take the treats. Ruby took them and fed them to the dog one piece at a time.
"Don't be scared. Clover will only be here for a few days."
Even the dog was named Lucky.
My parents had gone out of their way to choose Ruby's name, wanting something beautiful and precious for their beloved daughter.
On the other hand, my name came from Mom glancing out the window at a patch of weeds while she was in labor.
I remembered Grandma laughing as she patted my head.
"Poor thing. Even your parents don't love you. Well, they say having a humble name makes you easier to raise."
Chapter 2
After entering the house, Dad let Lucky go and set the shopping bags on the sofa.
Mom opened them and waved me over. "Clover, I bought you something this time. Come try it on!"
My eyes flickered. The last time she bought clothes for me was my high school uniforms.
I hesitated before walking over. Mom pulled a plain white T-shirt out of one of the bags. "Try this one."
The moment Ruby saw it, the displeasure on her face disappeared.
I carefully pulled the shirt over my head.
But the fabric clung tightly to my shoulders. I could barely lift my arms.
I hurriedly took it off and checked the size.
S.
"Mom, I wear an M now."
Mom froze for a moment, looking embarrassed. "I remembered that we bought you the smallest size for your high school uniform, so I just picked the same size."
Dad glanced at me and chuckled, trying to smooth things over.
"Kids grow up. No one can remember every little detail. Looks like the school food has been treating you well. You've filled out quite a bit, huh?"
Mom laughed too and took the shirt from my hands.
"It's just a shirt. If it doesn't fit, just put it aside for now. You already have plenty of clothes anyway."
I lowered my head. My throat felt so tight it almost hurt.
When I was living with Grandma, my parents rarely sent money home beyond what was needed for school fees.
By the time they finally brought me back to live with them, I was so skinny that my clothes hung loosely on me.
When I started high school, Mom bought the smallest uniform size for me.
As I grew taller, my sleeves became too short, and my pant legs rode up to expose my ankles whenever I crouched down.
I begged her to get me a new set, but she only patted my head and told me she wanted to teach me the value of saving money.
Then, she handed me Ruby's old uniform.
Ruby got new uniforms every year.
I wore her hand-me-downs until I graduated.
A sudden sting rose in my nose. I bit my lip and forced back my tears.
Mom had already opened another shopping bag and was holding a dress up against Ruby.
"Ruby, this one you picked is so pretty!"
I took a step back, intending to return to my room.
Just as I passed by Ruby, she suddenly lowered her voice.
"Sis, that T-shirt was a free gift I got after I hit the minimum spend. I didn't even want it, but Mom said we might as well give it to you.
"Who knew it wouldn't fit? It's not my fault."
I tightened my grip on my suitcase handle and gave a small nod.
So, it was something that Ruby didn't want.
I went into my room and turned on the light, only to stop dead in the doorway.
The bed and the small wardrobe that used to be there were gone.
In their place stood a piano, a full-length mirror, and a brand-new wardrobe.
I went back to the living room and asked quietly, "Mom, where's my bed?"
Mom was helping Ruby hang up her dress. At my question, she turned to look at me, her expression embarrassed.
"You're hardly ever home, and your sister has so many things. We let her use your room for the time being."
"Then where am I supposed to sleep?"
Dad put down his teacup.
"We moved your bed to the storage room. Ruby needs to practice piano at night, so you'll be disturbed if you sleep in there. It's quieter in the back."
Mom nodded along.
"Clover, your father and I have always felt like we owe you so much. That's why we keep teaching you to be independent. When you move to a big city, you might end up living in a basement or a storage room anyway. We're just helping you get used to it in advance."
As she spoke, the gold chain around her wrist sparkled under the light.
The teacup in Dad's hand and the bracelet Mom was wearing were both from me. I'd bought them with money I'd earned from my summer job after my college entrance exams.
I'd worked two shifts at the factory, including overnight shifts.
There were times when I was so exhausted that I genuinely wondered if I might just drop dead.
But the day I gave them their gifts, they praised me for being such a thoughtful daughter.
That alone made all those sleepless nights feel worthwhile.
"Okay."
I answered and turned away to retrieve my suitcase before the tears could fall.
As I silently cleaned up the storage room, Dad's irritated voice rang out behind me.
"We're doing this for her own good, but she doesn't even appreciate it! That's what happens when you're raised in the countryside. She has no social skills and doesn't know how to behave!"
Ruby sweetly tried to soothe him. "Don't be mad, Daddy! Isn't this just how Clover has always been? She's socially inept."
The three of them burst into laughter. With their laughter as the background music, I quietly made a little space for myself to sleep.
Dog hair was stuck all over the bedsheet, and there were several dried, dark stains near the corners.
I crouched down and dragged out a dog potty tray lined with pee pads from under the bed.
Lucky suddenly came rushing in and barking at me nonstop.
Ruby followed. When she saw what I was holding, she let out a laugh.
"Clover, why are you pulling Lucky's potty tray out? This has always been his room. He probably thinks you're trying to steal his territory."
My hands stopped moving.
Mom came over too. She crouched down to pet Lucky before looking up at me.
"Oh, that's our fault. We forgot to clean up the room beforehand."
She gave me an awkward look. "Why don't you just sleep in the living room for now? If you sleep in Lucky's room, he'll probably make a fuss all night. Besides, you only come home a few times a year. It'd be a waste to leave the room empty."
My heart grew colder inch by inch.
I thought that this family would've saved a tiny corner for me at the very least.
Whatever. It didn't matter anymore.
My phone vibrated. It was a message from my academic advisor, Ms. Foster.
"Clover, you confirmed your participation in the exchange program too late. You're leaving the day after tomorrow. Pack your things as soon as possible."
I stared at the message for a long time before turning off the screen.
When I looked up again, I forced a small smile.
"Yeah, I won't be staying long. I'll just sleep in the living room."
Chapter 3
I lay in the living room, unable to fall asleep because of the heat. The only thing I could do was turn on the fan and hope it would cool me down a little.
With a sharp click, the fan was switched off.
Ruby stood in front of the sofa. "Are you doing this on purpose to keep me awake? I've woken up several times already!"
Mom and Dad heard her voice and came out as well. Dad looked thoroughly annoyed.
"It's not that hot. Why are you still insisting on turning on the fan? Are you trying to keep everyone awake?"
They had just stepped out of their air-conditioned bedroom, so of course they didn't feel hot.
Mom unplugged the fan. "Clover, what did your father and I teach you? You have to be considerate of other people. Don't be so selfish."
She slammed the door behind her. I didn't turn the fan back on.
Sweat trickled down my back. My clothes were soaked and stuck to the couch.
Whenever I rolled over, I had to peel the fabric away from my back.
I'd spent over ten hours on a train and traveled nearly 600 miles. I was exhausted and starving, yet my stomach kept churning with nausea.
I lay there with my eyes open, enduring the night until dawn.
At 5:00 am, I folded my blanket and went to wash up.
When I returned, Ruby was holding my phone.
I hurried over. "What are you doing with my phone?"
"Just checking if it's a new model. Why is it so old? It's practically frozen." She held the phone behind her back.
I reached for it, but she suddenly dodged. The phone slipped from her hand and hit the floor with a sharp clack.
The screen cracked, and the phone went completely black.
I crouched down and frantically pressed the power button.
It was an old phone Dad had used for four years before giving it to me when I started college.
It held the only photo I had of Grandma, as well as a video I'd secretly recorded before she passed away.
"It was already falling apart," Ruby said with a pout. "It's not my fault."
I looked up, trembling, and slapped her across the face.
She instantly burst into tears.
Mom rushed out and pulled her into her arms.
"Clover Keller, have you lost your mind?"
"She dropped my phone! It had Grandma's picture in it…"
"Enough! Stop using your grandmother as an excuse." Mom glared at me with disgust. "We put a roof over your head, feed you, and send you to school. Is this how you repay us? By coming back and bullying your sister?
"If your grandmother hadn't died, we wouldn't have taken you back in the first place!"
The living room fell silent.
Dad avoided my eyes, but Mom didn't take back what she said.
I clutched my phone, stunned for a long time.
So, it wasn't that they finally remembered they had another daughter when I was 13.
Grandma passed away, so there was no one else to raise me for them.
Mom continued yelling at me. "You deliberately went to the cemetery as a child, just so people in town would accuse us of abusing you. That's what you're doing again! You're always telling on people. Have you ever stopped to reflect on yourself?"
I remember that day.
It was the start of winter break, and my parents had promised to pick me up from school.
I clutched my jacket and schoolbag, standing somewhere highly visible. I wanted to show the kids who called me an orphan that I had parents too.
But even after the school gates were locked, no one came. My calls went unanswered too.
I didn't have money for a ride home, so I carried my things and walked through the night until I reached Grandma's grave.
"Grandma, nobody here likes me. I miss you so much."
The town mayor scolded my parents over what happened.
On the way home, they spent the entire journey asking whether I'd deliberately tried to humiliate them.
Not once did they ask if I'd been scared.
Dad tugged Mom's arm. "Honey, that's enough."
Only then did Mom stop, finally realizing what she'd just said.
She glanced at me awkwardly. Her lips moved, but no words came out.
Ruby let out a soft sob.
Mom immediately turned and reached out to wipe away her tears.
"Oh, sweetheart. Don't cry. Does your cheek still hurt?"
I bent down, picked up the old phone, and went to a repair shop.
After examining it for a long time, the technician told me the storage chip had been damaged too. There was no way to recover the photos or videos.
I sat there for a long time.
I still remembered the video. Grandma stroked my head, telling me that I was the most lovable child in the world.
Whenever I felt miserable, it was the only thing I could listen to over and over again.
Now, even that was gone.
After some time had passed, I used what little money I had left to buy a plane ticket out of there.
Chapter 4
When I got home, Mom suddenly came into my room and handed me a damp towel.
"Some relatives are coming over for lunch. Wash your face. Don't embarrass us in front of everyone.
When I didn't respond, she softened her voice.
"I lost my temper yesterday and said things I shouldn't have. I know we owe you for leaving you with your grandmother all those years, but that doesn't give you the right to hit your sister like that.
"I scolded you because I don't want you developing a habit of hitting people. You'll only get yourself in trouble when you're out in the world."
She pressed the towel into my hands and reminded me, "And don't go looking so miserable later. Whatever happens in this family stays in this family."
With that, she left and went to peel Ruby's favorite fruit.
By noon, several relatives we were close to had arrived.
Ruby sat beside Mom, laughing and chatting with everyone.
I'd barely sat down when someone asked about my school. Mom sighed.
"What's the point of getting good grades? She's such an ungrateful child. Yesterday, she beat her own sister just because of an old phone."
Dad put down his fork too.
"We feed her, clothe her, and pay for her education, and this is the thanks we get. The moment we say anything, she drags her grandmother into it. It's like we've done her some terrible wrong."
My spoon stopped halfway to my mouth.
Ruby lowered her head and rubbed her cheek.
Mom immediately gave her an extra meatball. "Does it still hurt? Here, eat some more. I'll get some ice for you later."
No one asked how my phone broke.
No one asked what had been on it.
I lowered my head to continue eating.
My stomach ached with hunger. I'd barely taken a mouthful when Mom called out to me again.
"Clover, go get two six-packs. Get the brand your dad likes."
"I haven't eaten yet…"
"You can eat when you get back. We'll save you some. It's not often our relatives come over. Don't be so inconsiderate."
Dad placed some money at the corner of the table and urged me to hurry.
I put down my fork.
The corner store didn't carry that particular brand, so I had to walk another couple of blocks to find it.
By the time I returned, everyone had finished eating.
Ruby was curled up on the couch, holding a plate of freshly cut fruit and watching TV.
Mom casually took the bottles from me, complaining, "What took you so long?"
The table was covered in leftovers.
A few shrimp had been left in my bowl, along with a plate of pasta that had turned mushy.
I was allergic to shrimp. Ruby was the one who liked them.
Mom pointed at the table. "We saved that for you. Finish it, then do the dishes."
I stared at the food and didn't mention being hungry again.
As I turned to get my backpack, I saw a flash of green around Ruby's wrist.
It was the emerald bracelet Grandma had left me.
Yesterday, I'd carefully wrapped it in a handkerchief and tucked it into the deepest part of my backpack.
Now, the old handkerchief had been tossed onto the coffee table, with several used tissues on it.
Mom saw the relatives off and followed my gaze.
"Ruby found it when she was looking through your things. I told her she could wear it for fun.
"Didn't your grandmother leave you other nice things? What's the big deal about letting Ruby have this bracelet?"
Grandma hadn't left me anything else.
She'd worn that bracelet for more than half her life. Before she died, she slipped it off her wrist and pressed it into my hand.
By then, she'd grown so thin that the bracelet barely stayed on her wrist.
"Sweetheart, when you go back, if they don't treat you with love, just look at this.
"Remember, Grandma loves you."
I'd been so afraid of damaging it that I never dared to wear it.
Whenever I felt sad in this family, I'd secretly take it out and hold it in my hands for a while.
The photos and videos on my phone were already gone.
Now, they'd even taken this bracelet from me.
I stared at Mom, suddenly too exhausted to even explain myself.
They already decided that Grandma had left me other things. If I told them she didn't, they'd just think I was hiding them.
However, Ruby's eyes suddenly reddened.
"Forget it, Mom. Grandma only ever loved Clover anyway. I just wanted to wear it for a little while…"
She lowered her head and tried to take the bracelet off, but it wouldn't come off.
"If Clover doesn't want me to have it, I'll give it back."
"Good," I said. "Take it off right now and give it back to me."
Mom immediately frowned. "Ruby already said she'd return it. What's that attitude?"
Dad shot to his feet and slapped me across the face.
My ears rang. I stumbled back and crashed into the coffee table.
"You ungrateful brat! We try to talk to you nicely, but you keep pushing your luck!"
Dad snatched the bracelet from Ruby's hand.
"You're making a fuss over this worthless piece of junk?"
I reached out desperately. "Don't—"
But he'd already raised his arm and hurled the bracelet at the floor with all his strength.
With a sharp crack, the emerald bracelet split into two pieces. One of them bounced to a stop beside my foot.
"There. You wanted it so badly? Now you can each have half! No more fighting over it!"
I stood frozen, my outstretched hand slowly falling to my side.
Mom pulled Ruby close and turned to shout at me.
"How could you put some stupid trinket above your own family? We've raised you all these years, yet you're still so ungrateful!
"Pack your things and get out of this house!"
I crouched down and picked up the two broken pieces of the bracelet.
My fingers were shaking so badly that it took me several tries to grab hold of them.
Mom was still shouting, but I could no longer hear her.
I dragged my suitcase and walked to the door.
"Once you walk out of that door, don't ever come back!"
I didn't stop, nor did I look back at them.
…
After the door closed, the anger on Mom's face slowly froze.
"Robert, why didn't she even turn around?"
Dad's hand, which had been reaching for the doorknob, froze in the air. He stood there for a long moment, unable to say a word.